For five decades, Coppola has run his sets like high-stakes heists. He didn't just cast Marlon Brando in The Godfather ; he had to con the studio into allowing a "difficult, overweight" actor. He cast a 17-year-old Sofia (his daughter) in The Godfather Part III not because of a resume, but because of a feeling. He cast a non-actor, real-life gangster named Lenny Montana as Luca Brasi because the man was actually terrifying.

The irony of a film titled Casting 2 invoking Coppola's likeness is that Coppola's actual experience with "Casting a Part 2" is studied in film schools worldwide. When Paramount Pictures demanded a sequel to The Godfather (1972), Hollywood did not have a standardized formula for high-art sequels. Coppola initially refused to direct it, demanding complete creative autonomy and the right to title it "Part II"—a practice unheard of at the time, as studios feared audiences would reject a numbered film.